Universal credit rollout should be delayed as it is ‘failing too many people’
Citizens Advice produces fresh evidence that new benefit is causing debt and financial insecurity among recipients.
This article titled “Universal credit rollout should be delayed as it is ‘failing too many people'” was written by Rowena Mason Deputy political editor, for The Guardian on Thursday 6th July 2017 21.00 UTC
David Gauke, the new work and pensions secretary, has been urged to delay the mass rollout of the new universal credit benefit, after Citizens Advice produced fresh evidence that it is causing debt and financial insecurity among recipients.
The advisory charity surveyed 800 people who sought help with universal credit in pilot areas, finding 39% were waiting more than six weeks to receive their first payment and more than half (57%) were having to borrow money to get by during that time.
The report also detailed problems with the online application system and long waits to get help over the phone. It said nearly a third (30%) of those surveyed said they had to make more than 10 calls to the universal credit helpline during their application process, often having to wait over 30 minutes to get through.
The evidence from Citizens Advice is the latest in a long line of warnings about problems with universal credit, which involves wrapping six existing benefits into a single monthly payment.
Around two-fifths of the payments go to people in work rather than those who are unemployed, as it includes recipients of tax credits and housing benefit, as well as jobseeker’s allowance and disability benefits. The benefit is currently paid to around 530,000 people in trial areas but it this number will rise sharply in the autumn, when it is due to be rolled out to 50 new areas.
Earlier this year former welfare minister Lord Freud admitted to MPs that administrative problems and design issues with universal credit were causing about one in four low-income tenants to run up rent arrears, putting them at risk of eviction.
Freud, who has helped oversee the development of universal credit over the past six years, also suggested that the long formal waiting times faced by claimants before they receive a first payment when they move on to the new benefit should be shortened.
Citizens Advice is now calling not just for a pause in the rollout of universal credit until its problems are fixed but a reduction in the time period that people have to wait for their first payment and greater awareness of advance payment for those who cannot cope with delays.
It said it had supported more than 30,000 people with universal credit issues in the last year, with a quarter also needing help with debt issues. Gillian Guy, chief executive of the charity, said: “Universal credit is already failing too many people, pushing them into debt and leaving them without the means to make ends meet.
“Citizens Advice supports the principles of universal credit, but pushing ahead with rollout while the system remains beset with problems will put thousands more families at financial risk.
“The government needs to pause plans to accelerate the rollout of full service universal credit this autumn and devote the time and resource needed to tackle the key problems which mean the system is not working.”
The Department for Work and Pensions insisted the vast majority of claimants have said they were satisfied with universal credit and argued the survey of 800 people seeking help for problems was unrepresentative.
A spokesman for the deparment said: “As Citizens Advice makes clear, this report is based on evidence from a self-selecting group of people and is not representative of the half a million people claiming universal credit.
“The best way to help people pay their rent and improve their lives is to help them into work, and under universal credit people are moving into work faster and staying in work longer than under the old system.
“Universal credit is designed to mirror the way many people in work are paid, and we have budgeting advice and benefit advances available for anyone who needs extra help.
“The vast majority of claimants have told us they are satisfied with UC. We are rolling out universal credit in a gradual, safe and secure way, and in the rare cases where issues arise, we work closely with local authorities and landlords to support people when they need it.”
guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010