Powered by Guardian.co.ukThis article titled “McDonnell defends calling Tory MP ‘stain of inhumanity'” was written by Anushka Asthana Political Editor, for theguardian.com on Sunday 25th September 2016 10.39 UTC

John McDonnell has defended describing a Conservative MP as a “stain of inhumanity” by arguing that it is better if politicians are honest about the way they feel.

The shadow chancellor conceded “I was angry” when he made the comments in the Commons about Esther McVey in March last year, before she lost her Wirral West seat to Labour.

McDonnell was facing questions in parliament from MPs annoyed about his refusal to apologise for quoting a constituent who had shouted out that they wanted to “lynch” McVey.

He responded by saying that there was nothing to say sorry for about the substance of the complaint, accused McVey of trying to be a victim, and referring to the Tory employment minister as “the stain of inhumanity”.

Asked about the controversy at Labour conference on Sunday morning, he told ITV’s Robert Peston: “I simply reported what was shouted out at a public meeting.”

Pushed on his “stain of inhumanity” comment, he added: “Well, I was angry. Sometimes you need to express honest anger and that was about what the last government was doing to people with disabilities. It was appalling, to be frank, and sometimes it is better to be honest with people about how you feel.

“At times in parliament it means using strong language, but if it reflects your honest views it is better to be honest than to be in any way deceptive.”

McDonnell said people were fed up with “spin and triangulation” and wanted politicians to express the “truth”. He conceded: “There has to be an element of expressing yourself in language that doesn’t go too far – I accept that and occasionally I’ve gone too far and I’ve admitted that, but we have to be straight with one another.”

He argued that the honesty of Jeremy Corbyn was what attracted voters: “What you see is what you get.”

McDonnell’s refusal to back down on the comments could anger female colleagues, who have warned that they have faced a great deal of misogynistic abuse in recent months as tensions in the Labour party have risen.

guardian.co.uk © Guardian News & Media Limited 2010

Published via the Guardian News Feed plugin for WordPress.

       
  • florrie webster

    when the remploy factories were shut down by this government, a man who worked for remploy was on tv saying there was nothing for him now, he was unemployed and could not get s job like a lot of other workers for remploy. Esther McVey was on and she said a lot about the workers having personalised packages to help them with work etc. the man looked bemused and said nothing was been done ,Esther McVey said she would personally make sure he would have the right help and would be in work. The presenter of the tv programme said about getting them both back on the tv in six months time to see if what she was saying was true. I dont think it happened. the look on the mans face I will never forget the way he looked at Ms McVey, He thought she was barmy.